Title
HLC#23-007: Public hearing to consider a request for exterior alterations to the C.A. Smith & Sons Building, 1895, including a new storefront, awning and signage, at 126 N. Main Street by Ann Smith and Sheri Bumgardner, applicants, and Dr. Robert A. Smith, owner
Requested Action
To consider the proposed rehabilitation of the front façade at 126 N. Main Street
Recommendation
Staff recommends approval of the exterior modifications provided that the Historic Landmark Commission and the applicant come to an agreement on paint colors and signage at the meeting.
Description/History
The owner of the C.A. Smith & Sons Building proposes a major rehabilitation of the storefront, including a new awning and signage. The building is currently occupied by Dr. Robert Smith’s optometry office and the Lil’ Blue Goat art store.
Architectural Review
This building is a one-part commercial block. Facades on this type of building typically consist of plate glass windows topped with bands of fixed pane transom windows. The transom windows of this building are currently covered. The storefront may have incorporated a central recessed door at one time, flanked by display windows. Architectural detailing, such as corbeled brick, ornamental panels, parapet walls and cast-stone coping enhance the upper wall.
In general, Mansfield's commercial buildings use load bearing brick construction of one to two stories. Typical are rectangular plans with narrow frontage and very deep lengths that reflect 19th and early 20th century commercial design and marketing strategies. Brick and cast stone are the most used building materials. Most roofs are flat or slightly inclined.
The work is described in the sections below with the applicable standards from the Design Guidelines for Downtown Mansfield. The Commission must consider the standards when reviewing changes or alterations to landmark buildings.
Storefront
The following modifications are proposed for the storefront for both op...
Click here for full text